IMPORTANT - Only the creator of the review and the Admin can reply to each other.
You need to be logged in to write your reply. As the person who wrote the review you can only reply by logging in with the same account you used to create the review. As the Admin you must log in with your site username and password to post a reply to the reviewer.
Once logged in you will be redirected back to the review to write your reply
To respond to a reply you must login with the same account that you used to write the original review.
Admin must login with their site account to be able to reply to a reviewer.